M.K. Ghandi said to the British Raj, sure, we will make mistakes but they will be our mistakes for our own land.
An independent Scotland will not be perfect but it will be Scottish.
If I were a Scot, I would be voting yes.
Having said that, from an entirely selfish viewpoint, I hope the Scots vote No. If they leave us, they may sentence us to decades of Tory rule! Take pity, please!